THE DAY I ALMOST QUIT COMMUNITY OUTREACH

I'll never forget standing in the church parking lot on a Saturday afternoon in 2004, watching one of our last volunteers drive away after our "Great Day of Service." We'd just completed what many said was our most successful outreach event ever. Over 2000 volunteers. Over 90 community locations. A local news crew had even shown up to film our church "making a difference."

I should have been celebrating.

Instead, I wondered if I should quit community outreach ministry altogether.

══════════════════════════════════════════════════════

THE PATTERN I COULDN'T SEE

In my first years of ministry, I was absolutely convinced that the key to mobilizing a church for community impact was big events. Church-wide service days. Annual outreach projects. Massive volunteer mobilizations that got everyone involved at once.

It made perfect sense to me:

- Get the whole church serving together on one day

- Create momentum through large-scale participation 

- Generate excitement with visible, measurable impact

- Build congregational buy-in through shared experiences

- Attract media attention to inspire others

And it worked! Sort of.

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════

THE CRACKS IN THE FOUNDATION

But that Saturday afternoon in the parking lot, something finally broke through my excitement about big numbers and good publicity. A conversation I'd had earlier that day kept replaying in my mind.

The executive director of a nonprofit we'd just "helped" had pulled me aside as volunteers were loading up to leave.

"Kris, can I be honest with you?" she asked.

"Of course," I said, expecting gratitude.

"Your church's Great Day of Service is actually creating problems for us."

I was stunned. "What do you mean?"

She replied. "Do you realize that our regular volunteers don't show up for a couple weeks or more after you come? They figure the church handled everything. Plus, your volunteers painted over the mural our kids created because it looked 'worn out' to you."

She paused, choosing her words carefully. "The truth is, we'd rather have five consistent volunteers once a week for a year than 100 volunteers once a year for a day."

Her words hit me like a punch to the gut. But, she was right!

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════

WHAT I GOT WRONG

I started seeing the pattern I'd been blind to. The very strategy I thought was mobilizing our church for community outreach was undermining it. Here's what I finally realized:

1. Events Became Substitutes for Engagement

After our Great Day of Service, our church checked the "community outreach" box and moved on. "We did our part!" Instead of ongoing relationships and consistent presence in our community, we offered one-day solutions to complex, ongoing problems. We'd convinced ourselves that annual events equaled sustained impact.

They don't.

2. We Created Dependency Instead of Building Capacity

The nonprofit director's comment about their volunteers not showing up afterward revealed something I hadn't considered: our big events were teaching the community to wait for us rather than building their own capacity to address needs. We positioned ourselves as the heroes swooping in to save the day, rather than partners walking alongside the community for the long haul.

3. We Were Burning Out Our Volunteers (and many of our staff)

I'd noticed that the same core group showed up for every event, while most people participated once and disappeared. I thought the solution was bigger, more exciting events to draw them back. I never considered that maybe constant mobilization for new events—each requiring recruitment, coordination, and execution—was exhausting people. There was no rhythm, no sustainability, just constant asks for "one more event."

4. We Were Focused on the Wrong Metrics

I tracked numbers: How many volunteers? How many hours? How many people served? But I never asked: Are we creating lasting relationships? Are we addressing root causes or just symptoms? Are people's lives actually different six months later? Is the community flourishing?

The honest answer was no. We were counting activities, not transformation.

5. It Was About Us, Not Them

This was the hardest truth to face. We loved the photo opportunities. We celebrated the newspaper articles. We basked in the praise from church members who felt good about "making a difference." Our events made us look good, feel good, and get recognized.

But were we actually meeting the community's real needs? Or just the needs we decided they had?

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════

THE TURNING POINT

That Saturday in the parking lot became my turning point. I realized that many things I thought I knew about community outreach needed to be questioned. The strategies that seemed to be working might be counterproductive.

I almost quit because I couldn't imagine doing ministry any other way. If big events and massive mobilization weren't the answer, then what was?

I'm so grateful I didn't quit. Because what I discovered over the following years changed everything.

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════

WHAT I LEARNED INSTEAD

It took time, but here's what emerged from that internal crisis:

Relationships Trump Events

Sustainable community impact isn't built through annual events—it's built through ongoing relationships. Five volunteers showing up every Tuesday for a year create more transformation than 100 volunteers showing up once.

Consistency Beats Intensity

Small, consistent presence in the community builds trust and credibility. Massive, occasional interventions create dependency and disruption. The tortoise really does beat the hare.

Listen Before You Act

The community knows what it needs better than we do. Our job isn't to ride in as saviors with solutions—it's to listen, learn, and then partner in ways that actually help rather than harm.

Transformation Requires Time

Real change happens slowly, through sustained relationship and patient presence. There are no shortcuts. One-day events might create temporary improvement, but lasting transformation requires years of commitment.

Measure What Matters

Stop counting volunteers and hours. Start tracking: Are relationships deepening? Is capacity building? Are people flourishing? Is the community more resilient? These are harder to measure but infinitely more important.

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════

WHAT THIS MEANS FOR YOU

Maybe you're reading this and recognizing your church in my story. You're doing the big events. You're celebrating the numbers. You're getting the good publicity.

I'm not saying events are always bad. There's a place for church-wide service days—when they're part of a larger strategy, not the whole strategy.

But if events are your primary approach to community outreach, I want to invite you to consider a different path:

What if instead of mobilizing 200 people once a year...

You mobilized 20 people once a week for 52 weeks?

What if instead of five different annual events...

You focused on three sustained partnerships with consistent presence?

What if instead of counting volunteer hours...

You tracked relational depth and community transformation?

What if instead of asking "What can we do FOR the community?"...

You asked "What can we do WITH the community?"

This shift—from events to relationships, from intensity to consistency, from doing FOR to doing WITH—changes everything.

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════

WHY I DIDN'T QUIT

I'm so grateful I didn't walk away from community outreach ministry that Saturday afternoon. Because what I learned in the years that followed—about prayer, about strategic planning, about asset mapping, about sustainable partnerships, about volunteer mobilization done right—has shaped everything I do now.

The failure I experienced wasn't a reason to quit. It was an invitation to learn. To do better. To move beyond the walls of our church in ways that actually make a lasting difference.

That's what this blog series is about. That's what my book Beyond the Walls is about. Not perfect strategies or guaranteed formulas, but honest lessons learned through trial and error, failure and breakthrough, mistakes and discoveries.

Community outreach is too important to get wrong. Our communities deserve better than our photo ops and our feel-good projects. They deserve our sustained presence, our humble listening, our patient partnership, and our long-term commitment.

That's what I'm learning to give. That's what I'm still learning, even 20+ years later.

And I'm inviting you to learn it with me.

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════

YOUR TURN

Discussion Question: Have you experienced the "event trap" in your church's community outreach? What did you learn from it?

Reflection Exercise: Look at your church's community outreach over the past year. What percentage was event-based vs. relationship-based? What would it look like to shift that ratio?

One Thing to Try This Week: Reach out to one community partner or nonprofit leader. Ask them this honest question: "How can we be more helpful to you—not just for a day, but for the long haul?" Then actually listen to their answer.

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════

WANT TO GO DEEPER?

This blog post touches on lessons that are explored thoroughly in Beyond the Walls: Building Your Foundation (Book 1) (release date late February 2026), particularly:

- Chapter 4: Assess Your Community (learning to listen before acting)

- Chapter 6: Ministry Strategy (moving from scattered events to strategic focus)

- Chapter 7: Recruit Leaders (building sustainable leadership for ongoing engagement)

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════

NEXT WEEK: "5 Signs Your Church Is Ready for Community Outreach (And 3 Signs You're Not)"

Not every church is ready to launch significant community outreach—and that's okay. Next week, we'll explore how to honestly assess your church's readiness and what to do if you're not quite there yet.

═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════

SHARE YOUR STORY

Have you almost quit community outreach ministry? What kept you going? I'd love to hear your story in the comments below.

And if this post resonated with you, please share it with other church leaders who might need to hear this message. Let's learn from our failures together.